Hide table of contents

This is a linkpost for https://rethinkpriorities.org/publications/quantifying-and-prioritizing-shrimp-welfare-threats

The report is available on the Rethink Priorities website and as a pdf here.

[published June 2024, updated July 2024]

Summary

This is the fourth report in the Rethink Priorities Shrimp Welfare Sequence. In this report, we quantify the suffering caused to shrimp by 18 welfare threats to assess which welfare issues cause the most harm.

See a complete description of the methodology here. We focused on penaeid shrimp in ongrowing farms and broodstock facilities. Incorporating uncertainty at each step of the model, we estimated the prevalence, intensity, and duration of pain caused by each welfare issue. The intensity was based on the Welfare Footprint Project’s Pain-Track categories, and ‘pain’ refers to their definition of pain, encapsulating both physical and mental negative experiences (Alonso & Schuck-Paim, 2024a). We collapse different pain type estimates into a single metric: ‘Disabling-equivalent pain’. See the results in Figure 1.

Figure 1: Estimated hours of shrimp pain caused by 18 welfare threats, by pain intensity. Circles are means, lines are 90% Subjective Credible Intervals.

The average farmed shrimp spends 157 hours in disabling-equivalent pain (90% Subjective Credible (equal-tailed) Interval (SCI): [28, 356]). If we assume that 608 billion penaeid shrimp die on ongrowing farms annually (i.e.,  including those that die pre-slaughter; Waldhorn & Autric, 2023) then mean values imply that they experience 95 trillion hours of disabling-equivalent pain a year (90% SCI: [17 trillion, 216 trillion]).

The highest-ranking threats are chronic issues that affect most farmed shrimp. The top three are high stocking density, high un-ionized ammonia, and low dissolved oxygen. Threats ranked lower are broadly acute, one-off events affecting only a subpopulation (e.g., eyestalk ablation, which affects only broodstock). However, the credible intervals are too wide to determine the rank order of most welfare issues confidently.

 

Read the rest of the report on the Rethink Priorities website as a pdf here.

6

0
0

Reactions

0
0
Comments


No comments on this post yet.
Be the first to respond.
Curated and popular this week
 · 2d ago · 1m read
 · 
Hello FAST! We have good news this month: new cage-free listings in Peru! 1- HOTEL RESTAURANTS EL ALBERGUE consists of two restaurants and a high-end hotel in Ollantaytambo, Cusco Links: https://www.instagram.com/p/DHrNDEWyP8e/ Scale: National - Peru Who: Arba Failed tactics: None Successful tactics: Working from the beginning of the conversations with the entire team (management, logistics, kitchen, administration) thus generating a successful communication channel from each area. Scalability: This group is a huge cultural and gastronomic landmark in the Ollantaytambo Valley in Cusco, on the way to Machu Picchu. We are approaching new hotel groups in the area. Follow-up: We will stay in touch to request reports on its implementation. 2- RESTAURANT EL CHUNCHO Part of the El Albergue investment group https://www.instagram.com/p/DHonGYGygbn/ Scale: National - Peru Who: Arba Failed tactics: None Successful tactics: Working from the beginning of conversations with the entire team (management, logistics, kitchen, administration) thus generating a successful communication channel from each area. Scalability: This group is a huge cultural and gastronomic landmark in the Ollantaytambo Valley in Cusco, on the way to Machu Picchu. We are reaching out to new hotel groups in the area. Follow-up: We will stay in touch to request reports on its implementation. 3- BICHOS SPECIALTY COFFEE https://www.instagram.com/p/DHCEK_pxXmV/ Scale: National - Peru Who: Arba Failed tactics: None Successful tactics: Excellent communication from the start Scalability: This group is a huge culinary icon in Huancayo, Junín department, Peru. This is the first commitment of the area. Follow-up: We will stay in touch to request reports on its implementation. 4- DOPAMINE https://www.instagram.com/p/DGOLiz3OV1W/?img_index=2&igsh=MXgweHZzbW5obXNiYw%3D%3D Scale: National - Peru Who: Arba Failed tactics: None Successful tactics: Excellent communication from the start Scalability: New style of cafe, a un
Dydanimal
 · 4d ago · 1m read
 · 
Hello Fast! This year, the new aquaculture law will begin to be created, and we have launched several campaigns to raise awareness about marine animals and bring them closer to the public. One of these is our Save the Lobsters (Salvemos a las Langostas) campaign. A major Chilean supermarket (with locations in several Latin American countries) displays lobsters for sale in small aquariums that violate basic animal welfare standards and, furthermore, lack an internal protocol for their sale. In response, we have taken various actions, one of which is to alert the public. We have created a website to raise awareness about the situation, recently launched a petition for signatures, and as a result of our efforts, the Colegio Médico Veterinario de Chile (Chilean Veterinary Medical Association) has issued a statement supporting the view that invertebrates are sentient beings! This is very encouraging for us, as this is a highly respected professional body in Chile. We invite you to learn more about our campaign and reach out to us for any feedback you may have. We would be happy to hear from you.   Best regards, Marysabel Pavez Director Fundación Derecho y Defensa Animal (DyDAnimal Chile) marysabel@dydanimal.com
 · 6d ago · 1m read
 · 
Hi FAST!  The fight against fur farming in Sweden has taken yet another step forward.  This past week, the Swedish government has officially launched an inquiry into how a fur farming ban can be implemented. This follows a commitment made in 2023 and is the result of over 50 years of advocacy by Project 1882.  Last year, the government pledged to phase out mink farms and explore a full ban on fur farming. To support this transition, financial aid was introduced earlier this year to help farmers shut down their operations. Now, with this inquiry in motion, Sweden is closer than ever to ending fur farming for good. A legal ban is essential to ensure fur farming never returns.  The inquiry will outline how the ban will be enforced, with “animal ethics discussions” cited as a reason for moving forward. With the last mink farms expected to close to qualify for the government’s decommissioning support of 180 million SEK, industry resistance is fading, making a ban easier to implement.  Now, Project 1882 is urging the Swedish government to move forward with the inquiry without delay and to push for an EU-wide ban in line with the Fur Free Europe citizens’ initiative.  Read more here: https://www.project1882.org/news/major-victory-sweden-moves-closer-ban-fur-farming  
 · 3d ago · 1m read
 · 
Hi FAST Forum, Greener by Default is hosting a webinar for culinary leaders looking to navigate the current egg price volatility and supply chain disruptions through simple, plant-based switches. The webinar will feature a panel of seasoned culinary directors who will be sharing their tips, experiences, and tested, practical solutions to help attendees protect their operations from the impacts of the egg crisis. 📅 April 7, 2025 ⏰ 12 pm ET / 9 am PT 🎯 Perfect for: Foodservice directors, chefs, and menu planners 💻 Register here: https://us06web.zoom.us/meeting/register/zJnfBADkSAyAtmxsJj3HKg  You--and anyone in your network you feel would benefit!--are welcome to join us and learn how innovative operators and chefs are maintaining quality and consistency and delighting diners—all while reducing costs through smart plant-based substitutions. Our Panel: * Chef Nina Curtis (Speaker and Moderator) - Director and Executive Chef at Plant'ish & Co. Culinary Arts * Chef Cady Frazier (Speaker) - Executive Chef at Cherry Creek School District * Rob Morasco C.E.C. (Speaker) - Vice President, Innovation at Sodexo Campus In this 60-minute session, attendees will discover: * Real success stories from operators who've already made the switch * Practical tips for reformulating desserts, dressings, and other staples * Tips for maintaining taste and texture, while reducing supply chain risk * Strategies for avoiding potential challenges and pitfalls * Easy steps to bring these strategies to life for your operation BONUS: All registrants will receive a guide to successfully making plant-based egg swaps—including a helpful plant-based egg alternative conversion chart—courtesy of Chef Nina Curtis! Please feel free to share this webinar with your networks! The registration link can be found here, and if you'd like to quickly share, GBD's post on LinkedIn is here. Thank you!  
jennycanham
 · 5d ago · 1m read
 · 
Animal Outlook has launched its first Behavior Change and Volunteer Impact report, showing the results of programs that aim to influence lasting behavior change. Produced in collaboration with User-Friendly, the report documents some of the ways we can create measurable progress in shifting public attitudes and behaviors towards vegan eating. The report also shows the impact of volunteers in helping to maximize efforts in the animal protection movement. Last year, Animal Outlook volunteers completed almost 6,000 hours of work for animals. Read the full report here: https://animaloutlook.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/03/Final-Behavior-Change-and-Volunteer-Impact-Report-2024.pdf  Coverage in Vegconomist: https://vegconomist.com/market-and-trends/animal-outlook-finds-behavior-change-strategies-volunteer-efforts-fuel-growth-vegan-diets/