Hide table of contents

Today, animal protection groups Animal Outlook and Legal Impact for Chickens filed suit in the Superior Court of the District of Columbia, Civil Division, against DC butcher shop Harvey’s Market for misleading marketing practices regarding its foie gras, which is sold under an advertising banner with the phrases “humanely raised stock,” “all-natural,” and “free range.”

Please find a full press release here and below, and the complaint here. If you’d like more information, or to speak with the legal team, please contact my colleague Kathryn Evans at 888-581-8797 and kathryn@legalimpactforchickens.org.

Thank you,
Sage

 

__

Foie Gras Faux Pas? DC Butcher Shop Sued for Deceptively Advertising the “Fatty Liver” as Humane

For Immediate Release: October 15, 2024

Washington - This morning, animal protection groups Animal Outlook and Legal Impact for Chickens filed suit in the Superior Court of the District of Columbia, Civil Division, against DC butcher shop Harvey’s Market for misleading marketing practices. As alleged in the complaint, the vendor at DC’s trendy Union Market sells foie gras under an advertising banner with the phrases “humanely raised stock,” “all-natural,” and “free range.” But the foie gras comes from birds who were force-fed via tubes two to three times a day for up to three weeks to enlarge their livers as much as tenfold, and who were kept entirely indoors, according to the lawsuit. 

The foie gras sold by Harvey’s Market is labeled as coming from New York’s Hudson Valley, where the two largest foie gras producers in the United States—Hudson Valley Foie Gras, LLC and La Belle Farm, Inc.—are located. The producers receive thousands of ducklings each week. When the ducks hit 13 weeks of age, an employee starts putting a tube into each bird’s throat first twice, then three times per day, pumping food directly to the bottom of the duck’s esophagus. The producers do this to every duck every day for 16–21 days, and then slaughter the duck. As alleged in the complaint, this forced feeding causes liver disease (“foie gras” literally means “fatty liver”) and various other health issues in the ducks; repeatedly forcing tubes down their throats may also cause the ducks fear and pain. 

“Life is grim for the animals violently force-fed multiple times a day before being slaughtered for Harvey’s Market,” says Legal Impact for Chickens President Alene Anello. “The shop’s customers expect and deserve an honest and quality shopping experience, yet they are blatantly deceived about the feathered former owners of the diseased livers being peddled to them.”

“There is nothing humane about force-feeding ducks to produce foie gras,” says Animal Outlook Executive Director Ben Williamson. “Stuffing pipes down their throats and pumping huge amounts of grain into their stomachs is a cruelty that we can all live without, and one that has been condemned by top avian experts and leading veterinarians, and has been banned in the state of California. Consumers deserve transparency and truth, not deceptive marketing that hides the cruelty behind these practices. The truth is that the main ingredient in foie gras is cruelty to animals.”
 

ABOUT ANIMAL OUTLOOK

Animal Outlook is a national nonprofit 501(c)(3) animal advocacy organization based in Washington, DC, and Los Angeles, California. It is strategically challenging animal agribusiness through undercover investigations, legal advocacy, corporate and food system reform, and disseminating information about the many harms of animal agriculture, empowering everyone to choose vegan. Follow the group on X, Facebook, Instagram, or YouTube, and visit TryVeg.

ABOUT LEGAL IMPACT FOR CHICKENS

Legal Impact for Chickens (LIC) is a society for the prevention of cruelty to animals and a 501(c)(3) litigation charity. As featured in the Washington Post, LIC advocates for farmed animals by civilly enforcing existing cruelty laws in an agricultural context. Follow the group on X, Facebook, Instagram, or LinkedIn.


 

Contact:

Kathryn Evans, Legal Impact for Chickens

888-581-8797

kathryn@legalimpactforchickens.org
 

Ben Williamson, Animal Outlook

310-874 0009

bwilliamson@animaloutlook.org

 

PHOTO CREDIT: We Animals Media

1

0
0

Reactions

0
0

More posts like this

There are no more recommendations left.

Comments


No comments on this post yet.
Be the first to respond.
Curated and popular this week
 · 6d ago · 1m read
 · 
We’re thrilled to share a victory for animals and truth in advertising! Thanks to Animal Outlook’s lawsuit, filed with the incredible support of Legal Impact for Chickens (LIC), the nearly 100-year-old DC butcher shop, Harvey’s Market, has agreed to stop selling foie gras forever. The case, filed in the District of Columbia Superior Court, challenged Harvey’s Market’s alleged deceptive advertising practices related to foie gras. The lawsuit alleged that Harvey’s Market falsely promoted foie gras as “HUMANELY RAISED STOCK” and “FREE RANGE,” among other allegedly misleading claims. These statements were displayed inside Harvey’s Market in a manner that suggested they applied to every product in the meat case, including foie gras. AO and LIC argued that animals subjected to gavage (force-feeding) to produce foie gras can never be “humanely raised,” and that animals raised entirely indoors without outdoor access cannot be considered “free range.” Thanks to the efforts of LIC’s amazing legal team—Kathryn Evans and Alene Anello—we were able to send the message that deceptive claims about animal welfare will not go unchallenged. As part of the case, LIC sourced a unique poll of DC consumers to show 75% believe “humane raised stock” to be an inaccurate description of the birds used to make foie gras. A further 80% said they would not consider such birds to be “free range”. And when shown an image of the meat case from Harvey’s Market approximately 65% said they thought the signage applied to all products in the case, including the foie gras.  While Harvey’s Market did not admit liability, Animal Outlook voluntarily dismissed the lawsuit on July 1, 2025, following the confidential settlement agreement.    
Luiz Rezende
 · 4d ago · 1m read
 · 
Hi all! We’re happy to share that Super Festval, a supermarket brand part of Grupo Beal (former “Companhia Beal de Alimentos’), has officially published a commitment to exclusively source pork from group housing systems during gestation in Brazil by 2028, considering preferably preimplantation systems where sows are housed in stalls for no longer than 7 days. You can read the announcement in Portuguese on the company website here. Super Festval is a traditional family business with a local well-known brand and 39 stores in the state of Paraná, south of Brazil. The organizations Alianima, Fórum Animal, Humane World for Animals and Sinergia Animal engaged in corporate relationship with the company for 5 years of negotiations, combining strategies of friendly negotiation, technical support and public campaign warning to accelerate the commitment. The negotiations were positively influenced by the fact that Super Festval has a cage-free commitment fulfilled in 2024 (see their report to the Egglab audit). This is a successful case to strengthen animal welfare policies negotiations with retailers in Brazil. At the moment, it's important to increase the number of animal welfare policies implemented in Brazilian retail in order to promote progress in this sector that is traditionally less receptive to animal welfare policies. We will continue monitoring the implementation of Super Festval commitment, encouraging the company to report their evolution annually, asking to participate in Alianima’s Pig Watch report and extending its animal welfare policies to additional species, for example nile tilapia (Oreochromis niloticus). For the animals,
 · 5d ago · 1m read
 · 
Today marks a historic win for animal advocacy in Brazil, thanks to the combined efforts of Humane World for Animals, Te Protejo, , Fórum Animal and Change.org .  On July 9, 2025, Brazil’s Chamber of Deputies approved the Senate substitute for PL 6602/13 (now PL 3062/22), banning federal animal testing for cosmetics, personal hygiene products, and perfumes. Why this is huge: •⁠  ⁠1.6 million+ signatures delivered a powerful public mandate. •⁠  ⁠A decade in the making—originally filed in 2013, it finally broke its long legislative stalemate. •⁠  ⁠Brazil moves closer to becoming the world’s 45th country to outlaw cosmetic animal testing, sparing millions of animals from suffering. Besides us, the project had the support of many activists and other organizations and institutions such as the Department of Animal Protection that was created within the Ministry of the Environment in Brazil. Next steps: The bill goes to presidential signature. After enactment and a 60-day vacatio legis, ANVISA and other agencies will have up to two years to implement alternative testing methods and enforce the law. This breakthrough proves what we can achieve when we unite. Let’s keep up the momentum—share this news, raise your voice, and push for a cruelty-free future! 
 · 1d ago · 1m read
 · 
Iceland Foods committed to eliminating eyestalk ablation and implementing pre-slaughter electric stunning across their own-label prawn range by the end of 2027. ICAW has been running a campaign against Iceland for several months inclusive of digital actions, in-person demonstrations (including 70 people gathering in London in May) and other pressure tactics. Only 3 retailers have yet to commit to higher prawn welfare in the UK: Aldi, LIDL and ASDA. Thank you to everyone involved for supporting our campaign! For any additional information please contact Justine at jaudemard@i-caw.org